Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant: A Taste of Authentic Pizza in Peekskill

My BF and I ended up there bc our original choice was closed. What a GREAT find!! As a foodie I love trying new places and foods. I had the Tortellini a la Nonna. Cream sauce ones was perfect. It had bacon and peas that were not mushy and onions that were not overcooked. Everything was just great about the sauce. The tortellini was cooked to perfection. It was just an amazing dish. My BF had and Yogi in vodka sauce and he said the gnocchi was perfectly dense had an amazing taste and the vodka sauce was very very good!! I definitely recommend this as a great place to stop if you are just looking for something without going to a big restaurant. The pizzas looked amazing and I don't eat pizza. And they gave us a complimentary garlic cheese focaccia pie, personal size. I don't like doughy bread and this was just perfectly crunchy. Because we were in a rush, I only got a picture of my dish Definitely going back.

Loved this place so yummy food wonderful amazing please do visit highly recommend

This is my brother's.Go to pizza place and I can see why. Enjoyed takeout of my first salad pizza and it was delicious. Ordered a small one and asked for thin crust which made it still doughy but crisp. The salad on top was fresh crisp and abundant. Even came with some balsamic dressing on the side but didn't use it because, as it came was flavorful enough. We also ordered a small meatball pizza, which came with thinly sliced meatballs covering the surface. on regular crust that was delicious as well. But I preferred the crispness of the thin crust and recommend it. Good balance of dough, sauce, cheese and topping.

I stopped by Nonna’s with a few friends and ordered a Grilled Chicken pie to go; the service was awesome, there were lots of friendly faces and our food came out fast! And I mean, look at this pizza; Mouthwatering! We’ll definitely be back! :) One girl in the front; I think her name was Serena?? She was super sweet, we had just came from out of town and her customer service made me feel bad for leaving, Next time I’ll dine in for sure! :)

I just ate from there. The service was really good. The food is really good, too, each time I’ve been there. I recommend it highly, if you’re in the area and in the mood for Italian food.

This is hands down the BEST place to get Italian food in Peekskill! The food is delicious, I've had quite a few dishes from there, the fettuccine carbonara is absolute perfection. The pizza is always perfect, no matter what slice you pick. Plus, when you are there, the staff makes you feel like family. I will absolutely be coming back again and again. Its not pizza night if it isn't Nonnas!

Out of the local pizza places, my boyfriend likes this one the most and he is a very picky New York pizza eater. Yesterday/Sunday I tried one of the pastas, Seafood Fra Diavolo. Got the cannolis as well. Also good. Would order again, good prices for a nice meal. I’ve ordered delivery a few times and haven’t been in person yet, can’t rate the atmosphere.

The variety alone was great. Slices are not too bready with a nice crunch. We would highly recommend. I enjoyed the Classic Vegetarian and my husband the BBQ chicken slice. Staff were very attentive and friendly. We were even asked if we enjoyed the food and to have a great day upon leaving.